# MIP113: Governance Scope

## 0: The Governance Scope

The Governance Scope covers rules that regulate the critical balance of power, and adjudicate on appeals processes related to misalignment in the ecosystem.

## 1: Scope Improvement

### 1.1: The Governance Advisory Council

The Governance Advisory Council is a group of Ecosystem Actors that have been approved by Maker Governance to carry out advisory work related to improving the content of the Governance Scope Artifact.

#### 1.1.1: Governance Advisory Council Membership Management

Members of the Advisory Council are directly approved by Maker Governance through a governance poll, and must fulfill specific criteria.

**1.1.1.1**

The Governance Facilitators must ensure that potential Advisory Council Members can apply to be approved by Maker Governance, using an open process with clear instructions as per *1.1.1.3*.

**1.1.1.2**

Advisory Council Members must be Ecosystem Actors that are not involved in any business, political, or other governance-related activity that could result in a conflict of interest, either directly or indirectly. They must also have relevant skills for providing professional expert input on the content that the Governance Scope is covering.

**1.1.1.3**

The Governance Facilitators must periodically, when it is relevant, review the Advisory Council Applications, and if they find applications that are suitable, bring them to a vote through an MKR governance poll. When Advisory Council Applications are posted on the Maker Forum, which must follow the template as per *1.1.2.4.1A*, the Governance Facilitators have a review period of 30 days. During this review period, the applicant must host a Community Q\&A and shall answer as many questions and doubts as possible.

**1.1.1.3.1**

The Governance Facilitators can extend this deadline, if necessary, by 15 days, provided they posted the justification in the Maker Forum.

**1.1.1.3.2**

Once the review period is ended, the Governance Facilitators must publish the response to the application on the Forum, along with a description of the reasoning behind the decision. If approved, the application will continue with the Governance Process and proceed to a vote as per *1.1.1.3*.

**1.1.1.3.3**

Upon a successful vote, the Governance Facilitators must arrange a service contract with the Advisory Council member, which must be made public. Approved Advisory Council Members are added to *1.1.1.6.1A*.

**1.1.1.3.4**

Approved Advisory Council members have a term of service of 18 months from the time they are approved by Maker Governance. If desired, the Advisory Council Member can submit a new application for re-election when their term has between 60 and 30 days remaining. The re-election application must also fulfill *1.1.2* requirements and will open a new review period of 30 days where the Maker Community can provide feedback. The applicant shall again host a Community Q\&A and respond to as many questions and doubts as possible. If approved, the re-election application will continue with the Governance Process and proceed to a vote as per *1.1.1.3*.

**1.1.1.4**

The Governance Facilitators may, if they deem it necessary, trigger a vote to remove an Advisory Council Member. If an Advisory Council Member has not done any paid work for the Scope for at least 1 year, then the Governance Facilitators can choose to remove them at will, if they deem it necessary.

**1.1.1.5: Governance Advisory Council Requirements**

**1.1.1.5.1**

Governance Advisory Council members can be individuals, groups of people, legal entities, or companies. They can be anonymous, pseudonymous, or known entities. Governance Advisory Council members must be aligned with the long-term goals of MakerDAO Endgame. The Governance Scope Advisory Council is crucial in this stage of changes that Maker Governance is going through. This council should be composed of highly skilled entities who can quickly adapt to constant changes. They should have or be willing to attain a deep understanding of the Maker Ecosystem and its endgame goals. They should also be aligned with the Atlas and Scope Artifacts.

**1.1.1.5.2**

Desired competencies for members of the Governance Advisory Council, as many of the following as possible:

1. Deep understanding of MakerDAO, both at the protocol and governance level.
2. Deep and proven thought leadership in the field of decentralized governance, common good stewardship or other processes that coordinate a very large number of independent and often unpaid actors.
3. Hands-on experience in running a DAO or another plurality protocol. Examples include DeSoc movement, Twitter Community Notes, and Wikipedia.
4. Specializations in any of the following fields: political science - particularly specializing in power dynamics, international trade, law, psychology, business administration, philosophy - ideally specializing in game theory, and any other science that can benefit governance.
5. Deep understanding of voting systems and their effects on candidate selection.
6. Experience in people and resource management.
7. Leadership skills and ability to handle pressure.
8. Strong reading comprehension, excellent writing skills, and the ability to interpret whitepapers or large documents. Proven ability to communicate well and distill complex matters into simple, applicable terms, even under pressure.
9. Deep understanding of consensus systems and game theory.
10. Longstanding experience in moderation of high velocity and/or high impact forums or chats.
11. Understanding of legal philosophy or arbitration processes.

**1.1.1.6**

The current approved Governance Advisory Council Members are recorded in *1.1.1.6.1A*.

**1.1.1.6.1A**

¤¤¤

Current list of Advisory Council Members:

N/A

¤¤¤

#### 1.1.2: Governance Advisory Council Recognition

**1.1.2.1**

In order to be eligible for the Governance Advisory Council as per *1.1.1.3*, an Ecosystem Actor must post a recognition submission message publicly on the Maker Governance Forum.

**1.1.2.2**

The submission message must be cryptographically signed by the Ecosystem Actor address.

**1.1.2.3**

The cryptographically signed Governance Advisory Council Recognition Submission Messages must contain the information specified in *1.1.2.3.1* and *1.1.2.3.2*.

**1.1.2.3.1**

The following text must be included: “\[Name] Governance Advisory Council Recognition"

**1.1.2.3.2**

A timestamp recording the time and date that the message was signed.

**1.1.2.4**

The submission message must follow the template *1.1.2.4.1A*

**1.1.2.4.1A**

```
Title: [Name] Governance Advisory Council Recognition Submission
        - [Ecosystem Actor Ethereum address]
        - [Cryptographically signed Advisory Council Recognition Submission Message]
        - Applicant's name: [Company, team, or individual]
        - Any other relevant identifying details:
            - Twitter:
            - Website:
            - Email:
            - Maker Forum:
            - Telegram:
            - LinkedIn:
            - Discord:
            - Github:
            - Other:
        - Presentation: [Introduction]
        - Ethos and Vision:
        - Team: [Founders and team members. Brief description of their skills and backgrounds]
        - Services: [What is your company specialized in? What kind of services do you offer?]
	      - Experience: [A detailed history of relevant previous experience]
        - Client References: [Who are your clients, what projects have you done and can you show the results of any of them?]
        - Explain how your skills will contribute to improving the selected Scope: [Which specific aspect of the Scope do you intend to enhance, and what is the rationale behind your choice? How do you plan to improve the chosen aspect? Provide milestones, if applicable].
        - Payment Details: [How shall the compensation for your contributions be structured?  How many hours shall the work entail? Detail as much as possible]
	      - Emergency Availability: [Would you be available on short notice to provide advisory support in the event of an unforeseen emergency? How short of a notice? What would be your hourly rate for emergency advisory services rendered?]
```

#### 1.1.3: Governance Advisory Council Projects and Funding

The Advisory Council is paid on a project basis to do specific work that improves all or specific parts of the Scope Framework.

**1.1.3.1**

Entities are encouraged to submit applications with the intention of enhancing a specific portion of the Scope Framework. Any can entity notice a problem in the Scope or something that can and should be improved and apply to undergo a process to suggest improvements. The Governance Facilitators should diligently encourage participants possessing relevant areas of expertise to actively engage in this process to the fullest extent possible. Accordingly, once this MIP is successfully passed, it is imperative that the Governance Facilitators promptly post a Request for Applicants to the forum within a period of 30 days. The Governance Facilitators may choose to utilize a Peer-to-Peer recruiting process, which involves allocating a portion of the Governance Advisory Council budget to incentivize ecosystem participants and community members to actively seek out applicants, providing comprehensive explanations of the process.

**1.1.3.2**

Each Quarter, if they deem it necessary, the Governance Facilitators must solicit proposals and find one or more suitable Advisory Council Member to perform a project that will result in output that can be used to improve the Scope Artifact. This work output will be presented to the AVC Subcommittee Meetings as input for their Aligned Scope Proposals. As many AVCs as possible should be supported this way, prioritized by the Governance Facilitators.

**1.1.3.3**

In case an ambiguous, uncertain or challenging situation arises related to the Scope Framework, the Governance Facilitators may publicly notify the Advisory Council Members to submit proposals for projects that aim to reactively specify the language of the Scope Framework to take into account the specific situation. The Governance Facilitators can then directly propose the change to the Scope Framework in a weekly governance poll.

**1.1.3.4**

The Advisory Council may produce work output that is not directly compatible with the formatting of the Scope Artifact. In this case the Governance Facilitators must either transcribe it themselves, or hire an Ecosystem Actor to perform the transcription. This role does not require pre approval by Maker Governance.

#### 1.1.4

The Governance Facilitators may produce advisory input on the content of the Scope Artifacts themselves, as long as it is focused on improving process and governance content. They are prohibited from providing unilateral input on expert subject matter content.

#### 1.1.5

The Governance Facilitators have a budget available to pay for Advisory Council Projects per quarter. All spending must be limited to only what is deemed necessary and with a high probability of producing clearly measurable value, and this must transparently be accounted for in a forum post at least a week before any transaction occurs. The budget is contained in *1.1.5.1B*.

**1.1.5.1B**

¤¤¤

Advisory Council project budget:

| Maximum Monthly Amount (DAI) | Maximum Monthly Amount (MKR) | Implementation | Start Date | Notes |
| ---------------------------- | ---------------------------- | -------------- | ---------- | ----- |
| 50,000                       | N/A                          | Manual         | 2023-08-01 |       |

¤¤¤

### 1.2: Governance Scope DAO Toolkit Integration

The Governance Scope DAO Toolkit module must be built to give a full and accessible overview of all data and processes relevant to the Governance Scope.

## 2: Atlas Immutable Alignment Artifact

The Atlas Immutable Alignment Artifact is the foundation of the Maker Governance process, and aims to guarantee a long term decentralized governance equilibrium. Atlas Interpretation is used to disambiguate elements in the Atlas with expanded definitions, in connection with specific decisions or disputes relying on language from the Atlas. To make the Atlas as solid and immutable as possible, all Atlas Interpretation is recorded to set a precedent about the spirit of the Atlas and how future interpretations should be made.

### 2.1: Principles of Atlas Interpretation

Atlas Interpretation should only be employed when the Scope Artifacts themselves do not offer enough clarity. The resolution of Scope Artifact ambiguity or disputes must be fully congruent with the spirit of the Atlas and prior precedent, while also clearly setting new precedent and help to prevent future ambiguous situations from occurring. Depending on the level of ambiguity, an MKR vote may be needed to establish the precedent.

### 2.2: Atlas Interpretation Process

This section contains the processes for proposing and settling Atlas Interpretations.

#### 2.2.1

Atlas interpretation precedent approved through MKR vote is contained as Strengthening subelements of this clause. A majority of Governance Facilitators can trigger a vote to add a new subelement if it is necessary to resolve Atlas ambiguity.

#### 2.2.2

Atlas Interpretation precedent made directly by the Governance Facilitators is contained in *2.2.2.1A*.

**2.2.2.1A**

¤¤¤

List of direct Atlas Interpretations:

1. Payments denominated in NewGovToken in the Atlas or the Scopes will be made in MKR prior to the launch of NewGovToken at the proscribed conversion rate listed in The Atlas.

¤¤¤

## 3: Scope Bounded Mutable Alignment Artifact (Scope Artifact)

### 3.1: Scope Artifact Appeals

Scope Artifact appeals are a process that allows any Maker Governance participant to trigger a review of a Scope Artifact. This can be in connection with the Scope Artifact failing to follow the Atlas Boundaries, or if it contains biased or otherwise conflicted elements. It can either be a general misalignment of the language of the Scope Artifact, or a specific situation where the Scope Artifact is being misinterpreted or otherwise violated.

#### 3.1.1: Scope Artifact Appeals Process

Scope Artifact appeal proposals are submitted by AVC Members, and can be accepted or rejected by a majority of the Governance Facilitators. If a Scope Artifact appeal is accepted, the Governance Facilitators must review it. Governance Facilitators can also directly choose to review a Scope Artifact for adherence with Scope boundaries and Atlas alignment.

**3.1.1.1**

The Governance Facilitators can by consensus directly edit a Scope Artifact to align its content with the Scope boundaries and other Atlas requirements such as neutrality.

**3.1.1.2**

A majority of the Responsible Facilitators can trigger an MKR governance poll to implement an edit to the appealed Scope Artifact that will align it with the Scope boundaries and other Atlas requirements such as neutrality.

## 4: Alignment Conservers

The Governance Facilitators must ensure the rules of Alignment Conservers specified in *ATL2.4* are followed. Governance Facilitators must act against Alignment Conservers if they break rules specified in the Atlas or the Scope Artifacts, or act misaligned. Any Governance Facilitator may do this directly.

### 4.1: Alignment Conserver Derecognition

#### 4.1.1

Derecognition notices are issued publicly and justification and reasoning must be provided by the issuing Governance Facilitator.

#### 4.1.2

Derecognitions are recorded by adding the identity and known aliases or associated entities to **4.1.3A**

#### 4.1.3A:

¤¤¤

List of derecognized Alignment Conservers:

| Date       | Conserver Role | Identity | Known Aliases | Reasoning Post                                                                                          |
| ---------- | -------------- | -------- | ------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 2023-06-08 | AD             | Bulwark  | -             | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/notice-aligned-delegate-derecognition-and-avc-member-warning/21099) |

¤¤¤

### 4.2: Alignment Conserver Formal Warnings

#### 4.2.1

Formal warnings are issued publicly and justification and reasoning must be provided by the issuing Governance Facilitator.

#### 4.2.2

Formal warnings are recorded by adding the identity and known aliases or associated entities to **4.2.3A**

#### 4.2.3A

¤¤¤

List of formally warned Alignment Conservers:

| Date       | Conserver Role | Identity               | Known Aliases | Reasoning Post                                                                                          |
| ---------- | -------------- | ---------------------- | ------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 2023-06-08 | AVC Member     | HKUST\_EPI\_BLOCKCHAIN | -             | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/notice-aligned-delegate-derecognition-and-avc-member-warning/21099) |

¤¤¤

## 5: Aligned Voter Committees (AVCs)

AVCs are standardized Voter Committees made up of Alignment Conservers that hold MKR and participate in the Maker Governance process as actors that are deeply aligned with MKR holders. They are subject to specific requirements, and receive various benefits, resources and support from the Support Scope. They have significant formal powers, but no direct physical power, making them well suited to be in control and making key decisions during normal conditions.

AVCs focus on making sure that the day to day Letter of the Rules of the scopes are aligned with the spirit of rules and Universal Alignment. The AVCs impact on Maker Governance is to make marginal improvements to the Alignment Artifacts that strengthen them. As AVCs make detailed Universal Alignment interpretations, they must all follow a particular Strategic Perspective that informs their subjective definition of Universal Alignment.

The Stability Facilitators must ensure that the processes related to Aligned Voter Committees specified in *ATL2.5* are followed.

### 5.1: Aligned Voter Committee Decisions

AVC splits are disabled until the launch of NewChain.

### 5.2: Aligned Voter Committee Member Recognition

#### 5.2.1

To become recognized as an Unaffiliated AVC Member, an Ecosystem Actor must post a recognition submission message publicly on the Maker Governance Forum.

**5.2.1.1**

A recognition submission message must be cryptographically signed by an Ethereum address containing at least 1 MKR, or that has delegated at least 1 MKR.

**5.2.1.2**

The cryptographically signed AVC Member Recognition Message must contain the information specified in 5.2.1.2.1 and 5. 4.1.2.2. The information specified in 5.2.1.2.3 and 5.2.1.2.4 is optional.

**5.2.1.2.1**

The following text must be included: "AVC Member Recognition".

**5.2.1.2.2**

A timestamp recording the time and date that the message was signed.

**5.2.1.2.3**

The desired name of the AVC Member.

**5.2.1.2.4**

The AVC that the AVC Member wishes to join, if applicable.

**5.2.1.3**

A recognition submission message must use the format described in *5.2.1.4*.

**5.2.1.4**

```
Title: AVC Member Recognition submission
AVC member recognition submission
[Ethereum address]
[Cryptographically signed AVC Member Recognition Message]
```

#### 5.2.2

The Governance Facilitators must maintain the list of Unaffiliated AVC Members contained in *5.2.2.1A*.

**5.2.2.1A**

¤¤¤

List of Unaffiliated AVC Members:

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                  | Verified Signature                           | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: |
| TRUEMAKER       | [0x4eFb12d515801eCfa3Be456B5F348D3CD68f9E8a](https://etherscan.io/address/0x4efb12d515801ecfa3be456b5f348d3cd68f9e8a) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/growth-cvc-membership-submission-request/20349) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16549) |                            5.016 |
| anathem.eth     | [0xa2fC3b7A5dA35D0418Ec46A9CcFc7f4a53084841](https://etherscan.io/address/0xa2fC3b7A5dA35D0418Ec46A9CcFc7f4a53084841) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-anathem-eth/20558/2)     | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16935) |                            0.313 |
| stefdelev       | [0xaAA1D204D78De81a6EfF5264928A6B49eE748050](https://etherscan.io/address/0xaAA1D204D78De81a6EfF5264928A6B49eE748050) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-stefdelev/21681)         | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/23668) |                          Pending |

¤¤¤

#### 5.2.3

An Unaffiliated AVC Member may join an AVC through the process described in 4.5 or start a new AVC through the process described in 4.4.

#### 5.2.4: AVC Management

The Governance Facilitators must monitor and record the status of each AVC.

**5.2.4.1**

The list of all AVCs is contained in *5.2.4.1A*, broken down by current status. The Arbitration Facilitators must keep the list current based on AVC creation, adherence with requirements, and AVC Decisions.

**5.2.4.2**

An AVC is marked as *active* status if it has fulfilled every requirement under *4.3* in the previous quarter.

***

**5.2.4.3**

An AVC is marked as *inactive* status if it has failed to fulfill the requirements under *4.3* for the most recent quarter, but has fulfilled the requirements for one or more prior quarters.

***

**5.2.4.4**

An AVC is marked as *pending* status if it has been in existence for less than one full quarter.

***

**5.2.4.5**

An AVC that has failed to fulfill the requirements under *5.2.4* for two consecutive quarters is no longer considered an AVC and is removed from the list in *5.2.4.7.1A*.

***

**5.2.4.6**

The list of all AVCs is contained in *5.2.4.7.1A*, broken down by current status. The Arbitration Facilitators must keep the list current based on AVC creation, adherence with requirements, and AVC Decisions.

***

**5.2.4.7.1A**

¤¤¤

List of active AVCs and their members:

[**KISS AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-kiss-cvc/20346)

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                     | Verified Signature                           |               Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                                    |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------: | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| IamMeeoh        | [0x47f7A5d8D27f259582097E1eE59a07a816982AE9](https://etherscan.io/address/0x47f7A5d8D27f259582097E1eE59a07a816982AE9) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition/20305)                      | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16252) |                                         15.910 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-kiss-cvc/20346)                 |
| DAI-Vinci       | [0x9ee47F0f82F1A6F45C4E1D25Ce95C321D8C8356a](https://etherscan.io/address/0x9ee47F0f82F1A6F45C4E1D25Ce95C321D8C8356a) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-submission-dai-vinci/21555) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/22586) | 0.900 (wallet holds 1 MKR, only verifying 0.9) | [Link](http://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-submission-dai-vinci/21555/2) |

***

[**Regenerative Finance AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-regenerative-finance-cvc/20354)

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                           | Verified Signature                           | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                                        |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| ACRE DAOs       | [0xBF9226345F601150F64Ea4fEaAE7E40530763cbd](https://etherscan.io/address/0xBF9226345F601150F64Ea4fEaAE7E40530763cbd) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-acre-daos/20319)                  | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/22051) |                            2.180 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-regenerative-finance-cvc/20354)     |
| SpaceXponential | [0xFF8eEB643C5bfDf6A925f2a5F9aDC9198AF07b78](https://etherscan.io/address/0xFF8eEB643C5bfDf6A925f2a5F9aDC9198AF07b78) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-submission-spacexponential/20612) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17142) |                            2.180 | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-creation-regenerative-finance-avc/20354/55)         |
| fhomoney.eth    | [0xdbD5651F71ce83d1f0eD275aC456241890a53C74](https://etherscan.io/address/0xdbD5651F71ce83d1f0eD275aC456241890a53C74) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-submission-fhomoney-eth/21666)    | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/23243) |                            1.000 | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-submission-fhomoney-eth/21666/6) |

***

[**Resiliency AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-resiliency-cvc/20353)

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                   | Verified Signature                           | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                                  |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Res             | [0x8c5c8d76372954922400e4654AF7694e158AB784](https://etherscan.io/address/0x8c5c8d76372954922400e4654AF7694e158AB784) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-membership-recognition-res/20352)            | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16492) |                            4.173 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-resiliency-cvc/20353)         |
| Harmony         | [0xE20A2e231215e9b7Aa308463F1A7490b2ECE55D3](https://etherscan.io/address/0xE20A2e231215e9b7Aa308463F1A7490b2ECE55D3) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-submission-harmony/21352) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21630) |                             2.00 | [Link](http://forum.makerdao.com/t/avc-member-recognition-submission-harmony/21352/2) |

***

[**Composable AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-registration-submission-composable-cvc/20348)

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                               | Verified Signature                           | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                                         |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| LDF             | [0xC322E8Ec33e9b0a34c7cD185C616087D9842ad50](https://etherscan.io/address/0xC322E8Ec33e9b0a34c7cD185C616087D9842ad50) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-composable-cvc/20350) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16614) |                            1.020 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-registration-submission-composable-cvc/20348) |
| opensky         | [0x8e67ee3bbeb1743dc63093af493f67c3c23c6f04](https://etherscan.io/address/0x8e67ee3bbeb1743dc63093af493f67c3c23c6f04) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-membership-registration/20446/2)         | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16668) |                            1.600 |                                                                                              |
| David Phelps    | [0xd56e3E325133EFEd6B1687C88571b8a91e517ab0](https://etherscan.io/address/0xd56e3E325133EFEd6B1687C88571b8a91e517ab0) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-david-phelps/20554)   | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17258) |                            0.278 |                                                                                              |

***

[**Sovereign Finance AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-sovereign-finance-cvc/20868/)

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                         | Verified Signature                           | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                                  |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| seedlatam.eth   | [0x0087a081a9b430fd8f688c6ac5dd24421bfb060d](https://etherscan.io/address/0x0087a081a9b430fd8f688c6ac5dd24421bfb060d) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-submission-seedlatam-eth/20836) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/18891) |                            1.040 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-sovereign-finance-cvc/20868/) |

***

List of pending AVCs and their members:

[**RISK AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-application-risk-cvc/20948)

| AVC Member Name        | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                     | Verified Signature                                                                                 | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                       |
| ---------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: | -------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| HKUST\_EPI\_BLOCKCHAIN | [0xE4594A66d9507fFc0d4335CC240BD61C1173E666](https://etherscan.io/address/0xE4594A66d9507fFc0d4335CC240BD61C1173E666) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-hkust-epi-blockchain/20939) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xc11f93b290673c5348400adfdab516f08b2fb7f3197dd024a2cc94a301243216) |                            1.007 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-application-risk-cvc/20948) |

***

List of inactive AVCs and their members prior to becoming inactive:

[**Growth AVC**](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-growth-cvc/20363)

| AVC Member Name | AVC Member Address                                                                                                    | Forum Verification                                                                          | Verified Signature                           | Verified MKR Holding (MKR) (3dp) | Approved to Join AVC                                                      |
| --------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------: | ------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| StableLab       | [0xbDE65cf2352ed1Dde959f290E973d0fC5cEDFD08](https://etherscan.io/address/0xbDE65cf2352ed1Dde959f290E973d0fC5cEDFD08) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-recognition-growth-cvc/20311)                | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16253) |                           11.999 | [AVC Creator](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-growth-cvc/20363) |
| flipsidegov     | [0x300901243d6CB2E74c10f8aB4cc89a39cC222a29](https://etherscan.io/address/0x300901243d6cb2e74c10f8ab4cc89a39cc222a29) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-member-registration-submission-growth-cvc/20308/33) | [Link](https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16730) |                            0.100 | [Approved](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cvc-creation-growth-cvc/20363/13) |

***

¤¤¤

### 5.3: Aligned Voter Committee Activation

If 2 or fewer AVCs are active, then newly created AVCs are instantly Active from the moment of creation. If 3 or more AVCs are active, then new AVCs have to comply with the activation requirements for a full quarterly governance cycle before becoming Active.

## 6: Aligned Delegates (ADs)

The Governance Facilitators must ensure that all the rules of ADs are followed as specified in *ATL2.6*

### 6.1: Aligned Delegate Recognition

The Governance Facilitators must maintain a list of Recognized Aligned Delegates, and maintain the process for applying for Recognition as an Aligned Delegate

#### 6.1.1

The current state of ADs is maintained by the Governance Facilitators.

#### 6.1.2

The list of all current recognized ADs is maintained in *6.1.2A*.

#### 6.1.2A

¤¤¤

List of current ADs:

| Delegate Name   | EA Address                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | Delegation Contract 1                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | Delegation Contract 2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          | Neutral Contracts (if present)                                                                 | Forum Post                                                                                            |
| --------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| vigilant        | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x2474937cB55500601BCCE9f4cb0A0A72Dc226F61">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16682">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x51f3067cB6a1185d1e8316332921d9501FC4c006#readContract">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21510">Signature</a></p>                                                 | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xC2DAea14891Fc47Ee76368Ce7c54C7b200FbA672">Contract</a><br><strong>KISS AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16681">Signature</a></p>                                                             | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cd-recognition-submission-vigilant/20457)                         |
| QGov            | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xB0524D8707F76c681901b782372EbeD2d4bA28a6">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16763">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x0a907fe3adb890db7db27a7f21e188a4127b2e7c">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16765">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x1dd6c65e6e22f196d5c2209f439d1f07d02ba7a4">Contract</a><br><strong>KISS AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21305">Signature</a></p>                                                             | [Formerly Growth AVC](https://etherscan.io/address/0xca0c8bedc85c2ec9b0dfb42b3f2763486ddea1b6) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/qgov-cd-recognition-submission/20494)                             |
| TRUE NAME       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x612f7924c367575a0edf21333d96b15f1b345a5d">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16777">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x87686C4Dd2FFd8e0b01f716EEA1573f829737e97">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16778">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xddECEAd383F2c22B4755ab32f56d48a4A1415258">Contract</a><br><strong>Regenerative Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16779">Signature</a></p>                                             | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cd-recognition-submission-true-name/20455)                        |
| 0xDefensor      | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x9542b441d65B6BF4dDdd3d4D2a66D8dCB9EE07a9">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16755">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xa4b28dd898A885ccE88CAa00261d9fe6CEed32bb">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16756">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xa67f820945DA8634D5B54Fe09cA74B1559b7ff39">Contract</a><br><strong>Regenerative Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21276">Signature</a></p>                                             | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/0xdefensor-constitutional-delegate-communications/20458)          |
| Bonapublica     | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x167c1a762B08D7e78dbF8f24e5C3f1Ab415021D3">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21271">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xe2bfDa5e1f59325E4b8dF5feaA30e4aB6516bf28">Contract</a><br><strong>Regenerative Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16766">Signature</a></p>                                                    | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xFE61acc408b63a5a03507A224398fa1FE8143F28">Contract</a><br><strong>KISS AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21270">Signature</a></p>                                                             | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/bonapublica-constitutional-delegate-recognition-submission/20451) |
| PBG             | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x8D4df847dB7FfE0B46AF084fE031F7691C6478c2">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16773">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x69b576a7e193a15a570ee5bb2149deb3f03537a2">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21570">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xc3b85930deca88e5bcb48fa8ebe935f97d5e412b">Contract</a><br><strong>Regenerative Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16771">Signature</a></p>                                             | [Formerly Growth AVC](https://etherscan.io/address/0x952dc79bcee652aad8cc9268d9c614fa166d0c1d) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/pbg-constitutional-delegate-communication-platform/20471)         |
| Pf              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x94A388BEC0769c3394A48dB4DaBE5F29994100B3">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16824">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><br><br></p>                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       | <p>No current active Contract 2 - banned by KISS AVC<br><a href="https://forum.makerdao.com/t/pf-recognition-submission/20520">Link</a><br></p>                                                                                                                | [Formerly Growth AVC](https://etherscan.io/address/0x62060879dfBB6dEf3B73CFC48f1f0595c0FeD505) |                                                                                                       |
| UPMaker         | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xbb819df169670dc71a16f58f55956fe642cc6bcd">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16997">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x8cC777Ed9eb3A3b9087591697eCb7F60f256CE4F">Contract</a><br><strong>Regenerative Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16825">Signature</a></p>                                                    | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x27194176525A0088E3Dc96973b22b01b15376eBd">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/16998">Signature</a></p>                                                       | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/upmaker-cd-recognition-submission/20577)                          |
| Libertas        | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xE1eBfFa01883EF2b4A9f59b587fFf1a5B44dbb2f">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17881">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x3237bc92a54A9666d7cD8f22514225e04a11B98C">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17780">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xC7dA3b9cC5ef0435681876B035556477afF71318">Contract</a><br><strong>ReFi AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17781">Signature</a></p>                                                             | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/libertas-ad-recognition-submission/20772)                         |
| WBC             | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xeBcE83e491947aDB1396Ee7E55d3c81414fB0D47">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17927">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x58dc40b5f9f0758ee43b0a208fe362c90fdfad4d">Contract</a><br><strong>ReFi AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/17929">Signature</a></p>                                                                    | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x5b0a4932dc9e253f9b15fd69f07b68e9874ea794">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21557">Signature</a></p>                                                       | [Formerly Growth AVC](https://etherscan.io/address/0xb086ec4303dc1514c09618c6c68ee444d6eee041) | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/wbc-aligned-delegate-communications/20828)                        |
| BLUE            | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xb6c09680d822f162449cdfb8248a7d3fc26ec9bf">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19057">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xEdc6c08960F517F233E8b6f5A5A61b6B19834deF">Contract</a><br><strong>Composable AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19058">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x445CB6c63c502fDBebD1B273F6AEa1AaD691e0aa">Contract</a><br><strong>Sovereign Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21625">Signature</a></p>                                                | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/blue-ad-recognition-submission/20915)                             |
| PALC            | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x78Deac4F87BD8007b9cb56B8d53889ed5374e83A">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19240">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xBe32ED2b57a2cb4074acCD7DB61446CAc8FFaB36">Contract</a><br><strong>KISS AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19224">Signature</a></p>                                                                    | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x97123BC7a0C17fC203cB42C5b618fA2055F0F49e">Contract</a><br><strong>Sovereign Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19225">Signature</a></p>                                                | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/palc-ad-recognition-submission/20955)                             |
| JAG             | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x58d1ec57e4294e4fe650d1cb12b96ae34349556f">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/tx/0xcb017d31235abb7303c01169de358ffb1307c622994c802e1016dcdde8707164">Signature</a></p> | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x36124ceE63Ae786eea41Bda0FB61B1b946E4C08c">Contract</a><br><strong>Sovereign Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/tx/0xe195b455598d8ba6079af3654511474ce3b9c9cfeb5d7f942d3b80b3d5f83f20">Signature</a></p> | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xfbEc297af3f4925966AB295a0771c420a9E85e08">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/tx/0xf7f5e596bee95f108d6a9661672033d81bc41cb1175ca02523587510b7b2f661">Signature</a></p> | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/jag-ad-delegate-submission/20972)                                 |
| Navigator       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x11406a9CC2e37425F15f920F494A51133ac93072">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19371">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x636Ff7CA03D91D8C5614394b4cC78C642a5e2Ce5">Contract</a><br><strong>ReFi AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19369">Signature</a></p>                                                                    | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x6235c806b6A7752e47A9adc815Ba343DF62A4A0a">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21459">Signature</a></p>                                                       | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/navigator-aligned-delegate-communications/20993/11)               |
| Skynet          | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xd4d1A446cD5976a11bd32D3e815A9F85FED2F9F3">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19702">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x644c092a5ccafc425ebf133123299a6397ae97d9">Contract</a><br><strong>Resiliency AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19701">Signature</a></p>                                                              | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xb6ca415fc42b3f96641d14280c3f3a0f078e50e5">Contract</a><br><strong>ReFi AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19700">Signature</a></p>                                                             | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/skynet-ad-submission/21077)                                       |
| Cloaky          | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x869b6d5d8FA7f4FFdaCA4D23FFE0735c5eD1F818">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19712">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x475efaC48a0A18660A7A26eE6bd5FEBF466930f8">Contract</a><br><strong>Regenerative Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21627">Signature</a></p>                                                    | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0xb335e8b70f95F28e79ACF58491751f83B0050888">Contract</a><br><strong>Sovereign Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/19711">Signature</a></p>                                                | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/cloaky-ad-recognition-submission/21082)                           |
| Penguin Soldier | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x41caF770eb0a9EeC0c9cC46F388ea5A76986E217">Address</a><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21884">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x5d97F2af00C767b7333FDC2B58d10FAFF9F51024">Contract</a><br><strong>Sovereign Finance AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21881">Signature</a></p>                                                       | <p><a href="https://etherscan.io/address/0x4D8C9c2Cd8846533967b07BECFC437542196Ad6A">Contract</a><br><strong>Composable AVC</strong><br><a href="https://etherscan.io/verifySig/21883">Signature</a></p>                                                       | -                                                                                              | [Link](https://forum.makerdao.com/t/penguin-soldier-ad-recognition-submission/21395)                  |

¤¤¤

### 6.2: Recognition of Aligned Delegates

#### 6.2.1

Aligned Delegates must be recognized by the Governance Facilitators if they fulfill the following requirements:

**6.2.1.1**

An Ecosystem Actor must publicly post a AD Recognition Submission Message on the Maker Governance Forum.

**6.2.1.2**

An Ecosystem Actor must deploy exactly 2 Protocol Delegation System smart contracts and specify which AVC Governance Strategy each of them follows as part of the submission message.

**6.2.1.3**

The submission message must be cryptographically signed by the deploying Ethereum address.

**6.2.1.3.1**

Since an Ethereum address may only control a single Protocol Delegation System smart contract, Aligned Delegates should cryptographically demonstrate that they control the Ethereum address that controls each of their deployed Protocol Delegation System smart contracts.

**6.2.1.4**

The cryptographically signed Aligned Delegate Recognition Submission Messages must contain the information specified in *6.2.1.4.1* and *6.2.1.4.2*.

**6.2.1.4.1**

The following text must be included: "Aligned Delegate Recognition".

**6.2.1.4.2**

A timestamp recording the time and date that the message was signed.

**6.2.1.5**

The submission message must follow this template:

```
Title: AD Recognition Submission
AD Recognition Submission
[Ecosystem Actor Ethereum address]
[Ethereum address of Delegation Contract 1]:[Followed AVC 1]
[Ethereum address of Delegation Contract 2]:[Followed AVC 2]
[Cryptographically signed AD Recognition Submission Message from the Ethereum address controlling Delegation Contract 1]
[Cryptographically signed AD Recognition Submission Message from the Ethereum address controlling Delegation Contract 2]
[Cryptographically signed AD Recognition Submission Message from the Ecosystem Actor Ethereum address, where this address is not one of the addresses controlling a Delegation Contract]
```

### 6.3: Prime Delegate and Reserve Delegate Slots

The number of PD and RD slots is modifiable over time, and must be increased or decreased as the income of PDs increases or decreases, in accordance with the Atlas. The current number of PD and RD slots is specified in *6.3.1A*. This single number applies separately to the number of PDs, and RDs, and also determines (by taking its double) the amount of AVC Member reward slots. The Governance Facilitators can unanimously, directly increase or decrease the number with 1 every 3 months. The Governance Facilitators can trigger a weekly governance poll to change the number to a new arbitrary number.

#### 6.3.1A

¤¤¤

The current number of Prime Delegate and Reserve Delegate slots (applies separately to both):

* 5

¤¤¤

## 7: FacilitatorDAOs and Facilitators

The Governance Facilitators must ensure that all the rules of FacilitatorDAOs and Facilitators are followed as specified in *ATL2.7*

### 7.1: Active Facilitators

Before the Launch of SubDAOs, Maker Governance directly chooses the Facilitators that are responsible for each of the Scopes.

#### 7.1.1: Core Units and Facilitator Management

During the pregame, the Governance Scope manages and provides the budget for Core Units and Facilitators, while designating their responsible Scopes.

**7.1.1.1**

The Ecosystem Actor name, Ethereum address and budgets are contained in *7.1.1.1.1A*. The Active Element is changed through the ordinary AVC process. Facilitator budgets are paid out even if the recipients are not active Facilitators, as long as they are using the budget to perform useful work for the Maker Ecosystem.

**7.1.1.1.1A**

¤¤¤

List of Facilitator budgets:

| Facilitator          | ETH Address                                | DAI per Month | MKR per Month | One Time Lump Sum (if applicable, only applies to March/April 2023) |
| -------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | ------------- | ------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| JanSky               | 0xf3F868534FAD48EF5a228Fe78669cf242745a755 | 42,000        | 18            | N/A                                                                 |
| VoteWizard           | 0x9E72629dF4fcaA2c2F5813FbbDc55064345431b1 | 42,000        | 18            | N/A                                                                 |
| TECH                 | 0x2dC0420A736D1F40893B9481D8968E4D7424bC0B | 115,000       | 36            | N/A                                                                 |
| Steakhouse Financial | 0xf737C76D2B358619f7ef696cf3F94548fEcec379 | 185,000       | 57.5          | N/A                                                                 |

¤¤¤

***

#### 7.1.2

The Scopes and their responsible Facilitators, or Responsible Facilitator Core Units, are contained in *7.1.2.1A*. The Active Element is changed through the ordinary AVC process.

**7.1.2.1A**

¤¤¤

List of Responsible Facilitators:

| Scope Framework | Responsible Facilitator | ETH Address (if relevant)                  |
| --------------- | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------ |
| Governance      | JanSky                  | 0xf3F868534FAD48EF5a228Fe78669cf242745a755 |
| Governance      | VoteWizard              | 0x9E72629dF4fcaA2c2F5813FbbDc55064345431b1 |
| Support         | SES                     |                                            |
| Protocol        | SES                     |                                            |
| Stability       | SES                     |                                            |
| Accessibility   | SES                     |                                            |

¤¤¤

***

#### 7.1.3

If all Facilitators of a Scope are unresponsive and not taking care of their duties, a majority of the remaining Facilitators can choose amongst themselves an interim Facilitator, that will then temporarily become the Responsible Facilitator for the Scope.

***

#### 7.1.4

Reserve Facilitators can help protect the continuity of Maker Governance in case other Facilitators become unavailable. If the main Facilitators of a scope become unresponsive or otherwise unavailable, the Reserve Facilitators can initiate a take over as interim Facilitators by posting their observations of inactivity or unavailability to the Maker Core forum. If the take over is not disputed by the existing Facilitators within 48 hours, the Reserve Facilitators are changed to Facilitators in *7.1.2.1A*, and must take care of the duties of the role until a new Facilitator is selected using the ordinary AVC process.

**7.1.4.1**

The Governance Facilitators can propose expedited onboarding of Reserve Facilitators in order to ensure enough Facilitators are available to guarantee governance continuity. This is done by posting the name(s), ethereum address(es) and scope(s) of responsibility of the proposed Reserve Facilitators to the Maker Core forum. This triggers a Governance Poll following the Weekly Governance Cycle. If the Governance Poll is approved, the Reserve Facilitators are added to *7.1.2.1A*.

## 8: Professional Ecosystem Actors

The Governance Facilitators must put in place processes to monitor the Ecosystem Actors for risks of conflict of interest between Advisory Council Members and Active Ecosystem Actors, and ensure that the Scope Artifacts and the checks they place on Active Ecosystem Actors are in Universal Alignment with the Atlas.

## 9: Interaction of Aligned Voter Committees (AVCs), Aligned Delegates (ADs), FacilitatorDAOs and Advisory Council

The Governance Facilitators must ensure to follow and enforce the principles described in *ATL2.9* to prevent misalignment of the core governance decision process.

## 10: Core Governance Security

The Governance Facilitators must ensure that adequate funding and research goes towards developing a long term solid and scalable Core Governance Security Framework, that must be specified in this Article and be in accordance with *ATL2.11*.

## 11: SubDAO Governance Security

The Governance Facilitators must ensure that adequate funding and research goes towards developing a long term solid and scalable SubDAO Governance Security Framework, that must be specified in this Article and be in accordance with *ATL2.11*.

## 12: Scope Bootstrapping

### 12.1: Bootstrapping Governance Votes

Governance Facilitators are empowered to use broad judgment when exercising their ability to make direct Atlas interpretations and edits to the Atlas and the Scope Artifacts, when this relates to unintended consequences or mistakes in the affected documents.

#### 12.1.1

In case of unintended consequences or mistakes in the Atlas and Scope Artifacts causing Maker Governance to function incorrectly, the Governance Facilitators can at any time run a Governance Poll to enable MKR holders to make a decision that will alleviate and resolve unintended consequences or mistakes.

#### 12.1.2

The Governance Facilitators can at any time propose to edit any content of a Scope Artifact through a Governance Poll.

### 12.2: Aligned Delegate Privacy Transition

As a one-time event, in the moment this version of the Scope Artifact is accepted by Maker Governance, all existing PDs and RDs receive one months payout at their prior rate of compensation, based on their ranking at the moment the Scope Artifact is accepted.

### 12.3: Aligned Delegate bootstrapping Seasons

The first Aligned Delegate season lasts from the moment this Scope Artifact is accepted, until the first deployment of the Sagittarius Engine. After the first deployment of the Sagittarius Engine, the next Aligned Delegate season then lasts until Q2 of the following year.

### 12.4: AVC Advisory Council Focus

During bootstrapping, until the Scope Improvement Articles of each Scope Artifact are well developed, AVCs must focus on making Aligned Scope Proposals that improve the Scope Improvement Articles. ADs must not follow instructions by AVCs, through Aligned Governance Strategies or Aligned Scope Proposals, that cover subjects other than improvements to the Scope Improvement Articles and/or Scope Advisory Councils. Instead, for matters not related to Scope Improvement Articles and/or Scope Advisory Councils, ADs must vote according to their own understanding of Universal Alignment and the spirit of the Atlas in a way that best pushes forward the Maker Ecosystem towards the Endgame State and strengthens the Alignment Artifacts. ADs must make use of the ability of MIP102 edits to distinguish between Article 1 edits and General edits of Scope Artifacts, to make sure they follow their AVCs GSL instructions for Article 1 edits, and treat General edits separately.
